“What are we?” is a question researchers have started taking seriously. For decades, relationship science mostly studied people who had already decided what they were — dating, engaged, married. The undefined, in-between stage that so many people now call a “situationship” was treated as a footnote. That has changed in the last two years, as psychologists and communication scholars have started measuring the gray zone directly, and their early findings explain something that generic advice columns never could: why ambiguity is not just uncomfortable, but a specific kind of chronic stress with its own name and its own mechanics.

Where “Situationship” Actually Came From

The word itself has a documented history, and it’s older than most people assume. Google Trends data shows occasional online use as far back as 2014, and language researchers trace informal use on sites like Urban Dictionary to the mid-2000s. It stayed a niche term until 2017, when then-Cosmopolitan editor Carina Hsieh wrote a widely shared piece defining a situationship as “a hookup with emotional benefits” — the article usually credited with pushing the word into mainstream youth vocabulary. By 2023, it had enough staying power that Merriam-Webster added it to its slang dictionary, and Oxford University Press shortlisted it as a finalist for Word of the Year (the title that year went to “rizz”). The lag between a word’s first appearance and its dictionary entry — roughly 15 years — tells you something: the experience was common long before anyone had a name for it.

The Research Finally Catches Up

The first academic attempt to pin down what a situationship actually is came from Mickey Langlais and colleagues at Baylor University. Their study, “Defining and Describing Situationships: An Exploratory Investigation,” published in Sexuality & Culture in 2024, combined in-depth interviews with an online survey of 261 participants describing their recent relationship experiences. The goal was deceptively simple: build a working definition of a situationship from the ground up rather than borrowing one from pop culture. A follow-up study by the same team, examining 109 reported situationship experiences from 89 college students, found something that complicates the “no strings attached” stereotype — many people stay in situationships precisely because they’re hoping the arrangement quietly upgrades into something official. Measured against clearly defined relationships, situationships scored lower on both satisfaction and commitment, yet people stayed anyway, often on the strength of hope alone.

A separate 2024 study out of Binghamton University’s Human Sexualities Lab, led by Melissa Hardesty and published in Emerging Adulthood, surveyed 403 undergraduates and zeroed in on a smaller phrase with the same function: “just talking.” Hardesty’s team found the phrase works as what they called “a label without a label” — a way for students to build real emotional intimacy while avoiding the social risk of openly admitting they want a relationship, which can carry its own stigma on college campuses. The ambiguity, in other words, isn’t always an accident. Sometimes it’s a shield.

Woman sitting at a table looking at her phone, waiting for a reply
Photo by Brooke Cagle on Unsplash

Why Not Knowing Is Its Own Kind of Stress

Long before “situationship” existed as a word, communication scholars Leanne Knobloch and Denise Solomon were building the theoretical groundwork for why this limbo feels so specifically bad. Their 1999 paper in Communication Studies, “Measuring the Sources and Content of Relational Uncertainty,” introduced relational uncertainty as a measurable construct: how confident a person feels about their own involvement, their partner’s involvement, and the relationship’s status as a whole. Their research showed this uncertainty doesn’t sit quietly — it actively interferes with how people regulate their emotions and interpret their partner’s behavior, because every text, every canceled plan, every mixed signal has to be processed without a stable frame of reference. A defined couple can read an unanswered text as “they’re probably busy.” In an undefined one, the same silence has to be re-litigated against the bigger unresolved question of whether this is even a relationship at all.

That constant re-litigating appears to interact with attachment style, the framework psychologists Cindy Hazan and Phillip Shaver established in 1987 when they extended childhood attachment theory to adult romantic bonds. People high in attachment anxiety — who tend to need frequent reassurance and read ambiguous cues as threatening — appear to experience situationships more acutely. A 2026 preprint modeling situationship experiences through structural equation analysis found that attachment anxiety partially explained the link between relational ambiguity and lower reported well-being; as a preprint, it hasn’t yet been peer-reviewed, but it lines up with what the peer-reviewed literature on relational uncertainty already predicts. The undefined relationship doesn’t create anxious attachment, but it does appear to be an unusually effective trigger for it.

What the Research Suggests About Getting Clear

None of this research treats ambiguity as inherently toxic — a University of Vienna thesis based on interviews with Gen Z students found many describe their situationships as meaningful on their own terms, not as failed relationships waiting to be fixed. But the pattern across the Baylor, Binghamton, and relational-uncertainty literature points the same direction: ambiguity becomes costly specifically when one person’s hope for clarity is being carried silently, unspoken, for the other person’s convenience. Knobloch and Solomon’s framework offers a practical takeaway that doesn’t require a psychology degree — uncertainty about norms, costs and rewards, and future goals can each be addressed directly, in conversation, rather than inferred from behavior. The research doesn’t say every situationship needs to become a defined relationship. It says the people who fare best are the ones who stop trying to decode the silence and start asking the question out loud.